TheMReport — News and strategies for the evolving mortgage marketplace.
Issue link: http://digital.themreport.com/i/1503450
July 2023 » thefivestar.com 61 J O U R N A L July 2023 and gender disparities in eviction risk that predated the pandemic. In the article, experts draw on the records of eviction case filings from cities across the country that were collected through the Eviction Tracking System. Those include five of the ten largest cities in the United States— Dallas, Houston, New York City, Philadelphia, and Phoenix—but also several smaller places like Gainesville, Florida, and Wilmington, Delaware. All of these cities were covered by some form of local eviction moratorium at the start of the pandemic, often closing courts due to public health concerns. However, many state and local governments began rolling back protections in mid-2020: half of these cities had no meaningful emergency eviction protections in place after August 31, 2020. Between the start of the pandemic and the end of 2021, The Eviction Lab recorded the filing of almost 600,000 eviction cases in these 31 cities. Under normal circumstances, over 1.4 million cases were expected to be filed over the same timeframe. Filings were reduced most dramatically in the early months of the pandemic, dropping as low as 8.6% of the historical average in April 2020. By fall 2020—with the CDC eviction moratorium in place nationwide—this rate had increased to approximately 50% of the historical average. Filings remained around this level throughout the CDC moratorium and increased slightly after it was struck down by the U.S. Supreme Court in late August 2021. Eviction filings were reduced much more in some cities than in others. Differences in how county courts interpreted and implemented federal eviction moratoria—as well as the establishment of additional state- or local-level protections—led to a lot of variation in eviction filing rates. Case filings ranged from 78.2% of the historical average in Las Vegas to 15.2% in Austin. Based on where they lived, a tenant struggling to pay rent was at much greater risk of receiving an eviction filing in Columbus, Ohio, than in New York. For example, except under exceptional circumstances, landlords in Minneapolis- St. Paul could not start the eviction process between March 16, 2020, and June 30, 2021. Over the full study period, eviction filings fell by 81.7% in the Twin Cities. Experts also explored what effect these protections had in different sorts of neigh- borhoods. One way of doing that was to look at neighborhoods that normally see lots of eviction cases and those that see relatively few. Pre-COVID-19, one in every six renters faced an eviction filing each year in a typical high-eviction neighborhood. That fell to one in twelve renters risking eviction during the pandemic. Reductions in eviction filings were much larger in these neighborhoods that normally see the most eviction cases. Eviction filings fell by almost two-thirds in high-eviction neighborhoods and only one-third in low- eviction neighborhoods. Of the 800,000 eviction cases that were avoided during this period, over 475,000 of them—almost 60%—were missing from the one-fifth of neighborhoods that normally see the most cases filed. The largest reductions in eviction filings were found in predominantly Black neigh- borhoods. Under normal, pre-pandemic circumstances, the typical majority-Black neighborhood in our sample had an eviction filing rate of 12.2%, 8.5 percentage points higher than that in a majority-white neigh- borhood (3.7%). That gap narrowed to 3.5 percentage points during the pandemic. Still, the typical majority-Black neighborhood had a filing rate during the pandemic that was higher than the typical white neighborhood pre-pandemic (5.3% vs. 3.7%). Even with filing rates cut by more than half, the risk of eviction in majority-Black neighborhoods was greater than the equivalent risk in major- ity-white spaces before the pandemic. Findings highlight both the potential and the limitations of public policies aimed at reducing the prevalence of eviction. New data shows that an unprecedented combination of restrictions to the eviction process, income supports, and direct ERA (Electronic Remit- tance Advice) payments to landlords and tenants resulted in a significant reduction in eviction caseloads for a prolonged period. In the 31 cities analyzed, it was found that 57.6% fewer eviction cases than normal were filed between March 15, 2020, and December 31, 2021. This reduction in filings was concentrated in neighborhoods that normally see the most eviction cases. Filing rates were cut by more than half in majority- Black neighborhoods and neighborhoods with the lowest median income. Overall, Black women saw the largest absolute reduction in eviction filing rates. Despite these massive reductions, inequalities in eviction risk remained, both between and within cities. During the pandemic, a tenant in Minneapolis struggling to pay rent would have been much better protected from the threat of eviction than an equivalent tenant in Las Vegas. While the absolute reduction in case filings was largest in majority-Black and lower- income neighborhoods, these changes did not eliminate inequalities that existed before the pandemic. Lower-income neighborhoods still saw much higher rates of eviction filing than more-affluent neighborhoods.